Winner of the 2026 Cabell First Novelist Award, Grace Olufunke Bankole’s The Edge of Water begins with one of its protagonists, Esther, reconciling her own limitations as a mother in a letter to her daughter. She writes, “A man may own the children, but it is the woman who imparts the culture. I hoped to give you, my yet unborn, the life I might have had” (16). Esther spends the rest of the novel grappling with all she had hoped to give her daughter within a culture designed to keep them at odds. Bankole does not merely examine the intimate relationships between daughters and mothers, but interrogates the concept of motherhood itself, stretching the reader’s preconceived ideas about mothering to their capacity through characters who measure the success of their lives by the distance they put between themselves and the women who raised them.
The Edge of Water follows three generations of Nigerian women who are all afflicted by oppressive cultural and societal structures more insidious than they could have ever fathomed. Readers are first introduced to Esther, a woman forced into a marriage with the man who, after exploiting her desire to be with his best friend, raped her. Then we meet Amina, the daughter who results from this union. She yearns to move to America, not only to seek better economic opportunity, but to flee the shame that has plagued her and her mother since her mother divorced Amina’s father. Finally, we meet Laila, Amina’s American-born daughter, who comes of age utterly directionless, ignorant of the life her mother lived before she was born.
At the core of all of Bankole’s characters is an inexhaustible yearning for more in their lives, either for themselves or their progeny. Ultimately, each character satiates their aching desires but at devastating costs. This empty satiation prompts the epistolary form to drive the narrative. In these direct addresses to one another and themselves, characters freely lament the mistakes they made while in pursuit of the dreams they felt they were owed and long denied. Despite many narrative themes reverberating through the novel’s pages, motherhood remains the central tenet–the altar at which our main protagonists practice true devotion, falling into despair when they come up short of the impossible expectations motherhood demands. Amina says this about motherhood in African culture, “Nigerian mothers and daughters oscillate between formality and smothering. No amount of love can supersede the respect a mother is due. Offense is ever ready to be taken–it is a part of the culture that keeps things in their rightful place. Still, nobody loves their child like an African mother. It is a love unto death, for better or worse” (104).
Bankole renders these tender and complicated relationships on the page with substantial depth and brilliant prose. While heartbreaking, these characters are brimming with life and nerve. Heart-wrenching but hopeful, The Edge of Water is a novel that doesn’t pull its punches when detailing the hard truths of motherhood, but also charts a path toward a future where mothers aren’t merely idolized, but cared for too.
